Skip to main content

Wanted: More "David Lean Style" Novels

It might be fair to describe the David Lean style movies (e.g., Bridge On the River Kwai, Lawrence of Arabia, and Doctor Zhivago) as consisting of a close-up drama of the main characters, usually during wars or revolutions, and with a huge landscape in the background. (Doctor Zhivago was the only one in the list that was pulled down by love triangles, adultery, and all the rest of that puke. And that wasn't really Lean's fault.)

To be a happier novel-reader I need to find books that remind me of Lean's movies. By luck I did. Tolstoy's "Hadji Murat" was written late in Tolstoy's life. The short novel took place in the same setting where young Tolstoy served in the Czar's army, the Caucasus, between the Black Sea and Caspian Sea.

Reading this short novel will probably make you feel like the ideal traveler, who learns about radically different ways of life, and not just silly scenery tourism. Of course there is plenty of scenery in the neighborhood, including an 18,000 ft high mountain! The main character, Hadji Murat, was a warrior in one of the Muslim tribes there.

The Caucasus was the southern boundary of czarist Russia, and what a boundary it was, ethnically, linguistically, and culturally! Muslims versus Eastern Orthodox Christianity.  Turkic versus Indo-European languages. The Silk Route went through there. It was the eastern edge of the ancient Greco-Roman world: the legendary Jason and the Argonaut looked for the Golden Fleece there. It was Josef Stalin's home country.

The Black Sea isn't the Russian equivalent of North America's Great Lakes. Salty water flows into the Black Sea from the Mediterranean along the bottom, while freshwater flows out to the Mediterranean along the top. The deepest spot in the Black Sea is over 7000 feet, compared to about 1000 feet in Lake Superior.

My goodness, what a map nerd I am! It's time to find some bicycle touring blogs that roamed the Caucasus.

Let's say you are a "Caucasian." Hasn't it always seemed strange to be affiliated with a place-name that you could barely point to on a map? The Indo-Europeans of the Caucasus became important to the world because that is probably where the horse was domesticated. Soon after, they learned to put a chariot behind a team of two horses; one guy managed the horses, while the second guy blasted away with a bow and arrow. They even learned to make lighter, spoked wheels.

What an important region the Eurasian steppe (grasslands) used to be! They connected eastern Europe with China. All of the ancient civilizations, except maybe the Egyptian, were invaded and conquered by horse and chariot warriers. It was the classic battle of Cain versus Abel. 

Anyway, this is the proper backdrop for an interesting short novel. It is so much better than the parlour and ballroom combat of 19th Century novels written for lady novel readers, or the modern novels, dominated by the perverse proclivities of New York City.

Comments

XXXXX said…
You say a lot about the history of this area but very little about the actual novel. I presume you have a library card there in Yuma...you might check out if they have DVD's from The Teaching Company there that you can rent. I am addicted to them and just finished a series about the common man throughout history. Anyway, there are many topics, etc. and you may very well find something of interest. I am picking up one today about the History of the Persian Empire, which encompasses the area of which you speak. Yes, this is an extremely interesting area with a mighty long and diverse history.
Joy said…
Ah, this post exemplifies (as in exemplar) all the reasons I follow this blog! Thank you for keeping that fine mind of yours well-honed. As a long-time student of Earth's history, I have sometime wondered if, just after the last glaciers retreated, a space wormhole or magical portal (I incline to the former) didn't open somewhere on the Mongolian steppes. The tsunamis of Dorians, Hittites, Scythians, Mongols and Turks (to name only the best known) that roistered east and west from there in a relatively short span of time are hard to explain in any scientific way. Then there was the Black Death, apparently the end of the outpouring. "It's a puzzlement," to quote the (fictional) King of Siam.
Our library does have DVDs of that type, I think.

You'll probably never see me talk that much about a book when I am writing "about" a book. I don't want to rehash and regurgitate the plot. What matters is helping somebody decide whether the book is for them. Who is likely to enjoy this book, and who isn't, and Why.
Yes, the Black Death. There is so much I omitted about the Caucasus, the Silk Road, and the Eurasian Steppe. It is better for the reader to head off to the Britannia.com or wikipedia articles. I just wanted to honestly gush over the area a bit, and let my enthusiasm rub off on somebody else.
Joy said…
It occurred to me this morning that there are magical portals in this world, but they're all between human ears. The stuff between my ears was somewhat impaired by a Bushmill martini when I wrote the above. Domestication of the horse explains a lot about the subsequent history of central Asia. Old Dobbin really speeded up things, didn't she?
edlfrey said…
kaBLOOnie, one small correction to your posting. The book "River God" that I read uses this period in history as the story background.

The Hyksos a multiracial people from Middle East who took over the eastern Nile Delta around 1650 BC, ending the Thirteenth Dynasty of Egypt and initiating the Second Intermediate Period. They brought several technical improvements to Egypt, introducing the horse and chariot but with a solid wheel. Egyptians are credited with the first implementation of a spoked wheel on their model year 2000 BC chariots.
I am still threatening to read "River God", except for my distaste for modern novels. But if you assure me that 20% of the book isn't lurid bedroom scenes...
edlfrey said…
I think less than 20% and those are not lurid. I think you might like it for the history which seemed to be well researched.

'The story is told from the perspective of Taita, a eunuch slave. Strutting about with all the substance of cardboard, the tale's comic book characters manage to have talents and characteristics that emerge just in the nick of time to move the story along.' Taita's braggadocious story telling was a bit off putting but he was conveying some interesting historical information while he did it.
Joy said…
Apropos of none of the above (except the glancing blow at NYC), I recommend the Dec.27 post by Vincent Mounier titled "Aerial Thoughts, Lost in the View" on his blog Coriolistic Anachronisms. Mr. Mounier and spouse Marie Viljoen prove that it is possible to retain possession of one's soul in the belly of the beast - fine writers, both of them.