Skip to main content

Israel and the Whig Interpretation of History

 It is probably shocking to many people how ancient superstitions still affect big events in today's modern world.  I would like to add modern superstitions to the last sentence.

The notion of Progress has almost become a Deity the last couple centuries.  I mockingly call that point-of-view the "Whig Interpretation of History."  You'd think that World Wars I and II would have weakened the blind faith in Progress.

Onto the World Wars, let's add the current genocide in Gaza.  I wish I knew Israelis a bit better.  But it seems as though they don't really worship Yahweh so much as they worship being Jewish.  But what does it mean to be Jewish?  To wear a cloth disk on your head's bald spot?  To grow curly ringlets on the side of your head?  Certain petty rules about food, unique national holidays, or speaking Hebrew?

Such things are interesting and help to put more variety into the world, but they seem too trivial to worship as a pseudo-deity.  Jewish Israelis have essentially made a Moloch-like Deity out of tribalism or nationalism.

Moloch, from Wikipedia

Then there are the Christian Zionists in the USA.  They think they worship Yahweh and Yeshua, but in fact they worship their own quirky interpretation of the ancient scrolls.  Perhaps they have never read a book about the history of Christianity and have no appreciation of how diverse the interpretations have been over the centuries.

Perhaps they are blind to that because they are Protestants.  The Original Sin of Protestantism is the notion that the Bible can interpret itself.  No book can.

Let's say that 1650 A.D. was the time period when European Christians stopped slaughtering each other over differing interpretations of the Bible, and decided to 'live and let live' over differing interpretations.  That was almost 400 years ago.  Despite 400 years of Progress, Christian Zionists are ready to excuse genocide in Gaza because of their quirky interpretation of a few verses in the ancient scrolls.

The current genocide in Gaza shows that Progress is a god with feet of clay.

Comments

Anonymous said…
Jews and Arabs have been trying to "genocide" eachother for thousands of years. They both suck at it. Both sides seem to still have a lot of people, culture, and traditions still going strong. Real genocide is what badasses like the Romans and the Babylonians used to do. This whole Jew/Arab thing is like road construction. It is eternal, ongoing, and will still be happening after we're all long gone.
from what I understand, the events of jesus and subsequent events happened decades before the actual bible was written. So, who knows what really took place. To me, the bible was fabricated and embellished. Rome accepted Christianity because there were too many people who believed it and overpowered the Romans. Now Christianity is politized...if you don't believe you are ostracized...you don't belong to the cult.
From the history books I've read, Muslims and Jews got along fairly well, most of the time. But you said "Arab", not Muslim. I don't know about Arabs.
i am happy about Christian Zionists continuing to believe in Christianity. I just want them to be skeptical with their quirky interpretation of End Time prophecies. The tiniest bit of skepticism should turn them against genocide.
Anonymous said…
Islam has only been around since the early 7th century. The exodus from Egypt by the jews is estimated to have been around 1500-1400 BC. The jews were at war with everyone in the region for thousands of years before islam as a religion existed. So whether it's Egyptians, Assyrians, Philistines, Arabs, etc., it's still just different tribal groups in the region constantly and eternally trying to "genocide" eachother. There were periods where the religions coexisted, but the tribes have always warred with eachother.
Anonymous said…
It will never end, ever. The sun will blow out first.
Perhaps it will end if we put the blame less on Jews and Arabs, and more on the imperialist powers that are behind the mess. The British Empire ended around 1950. The American Empire is ending right now.